Skip to the stories
Climate Science

China’s National Parks Raise Questions About Conservation and Community Displacement

By Nithin Coca 646 views

China’s expanding park system aims to protect wildlife, while reported displacement raises questions about local knowledge and conservation’s social costs.

China’s National Parks Raise Questions About Conservation and Community Displacement

China’s national park expansion is being presented as a major conservation effort. Yet the experience of communities living within proposed and established park areas raises a harder question: can wildlife protection succeed when people with generations of ties to the land are displaced and their knowledge excluded?

The plan, announced in 2015, began with Sanjiangyuan, a vast protected area on the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau. The park covers an area described as 13,000 square miles larger than Germany and 14 times the size of Yellowstone. State media has praised its alpine ecosystems, rivers and mountains. The broader plan initially covered 10 parks, intended to protect species including snow leopards, giant pandas, yaks and Tibetan antelopes.

International conservation organizations, among them Conservation International, The Nature Conservancy and WWF, took part in exchanges and conservation work in China. Their involvement reflected an opportunity to support habitat protection and share experience in park management. But for Tibetans such as Kyinzom Dhongdue, the parks also sit within a history of political control and contested land. Four of the 10 initially planned parks, including Sanjiangyuan, are in areas that had been part of an independent Tibet before China’s 1950 invasion.

Map of Sanjiangyuan National Nature Reserve

Dhongdue, a former member of the Tibetan Parliament in exile and a human rights activist based in Australia, says conservation organizations risk lending credibility to China’s presentation of itself as an environmental leader if they overlook the effects on local people. She and other critics see a recurring pattern in Tibet, Xinjiang and Inner Mongolia: new protected areas and ecotourism projects accompany the removal of residents, while park authorities or tourism businesses gain control of the land.

Reliable comprehensive figures on displacement are lacking. One estimate placed 652,600 people inside the boundaries of the initial 10 parks. Reports cited in the source describe tens of thousands of Tibetan nomads and villagers being moved, often to newly built settlements in less desirable locations. The scale of displacement among Uyghur and Mongol communities is less clear. The accounts nonetheless raise a basic conservation concern: a landscape can appear “untouched” in promotional imagery while being home to communities that have lived there and cared for it over generations.

Who gets to shape conservation?

International organizations helped introduce and develop the national park concept in China over several decades. The Nature Conservancy began sharing park-management knowledge in 1997, according to the East-West Center at the University of Hawai‘i. Conservation International says its work has helped conserve 4.9 million acres in China; an early project was in southeastern Tibet. For these groups, the 2015 announcement represented a significant conservation milestone.

The human history of parks elsewhere offers a caution. In the United States, the creation of Yosemite led to the expulsion of Miwok and Ahwahneechee people. Other parks and monuments, including Glacier, Yellowstone and Shenandoah, were also established on Indigenous lands. The wilderness image promoted to visitors often obscured those communities and their histories. Conservation organizations in the United States have since begun to acknowledge the harm and the role Indigenous peoples should have in land stewardship.

The comparison has limits. The source describes distinct histories and different systems of power. But it points to a shared conservation problem: removing people from a landscape can be treated as a way to protect nature, even when those people have long managed it. The Nature Conservancy, Conservation International and WWF have each stated support for involving Indigenous peoples and local communities in conservation. Critics argue that these commitments should guide their work in China as well as elsewhere.

Dawa Lokyitsang, a Tibetan anthropologist at the International Institute for Asian Studies in the Netherlands, says public protest in Tibet and Xinjiang is rare and dangerous. The source also describes restrictions on civic activity and extensive monitoring and censorship affecting minority communities. Such conditions can make it difficult for residents to challenge park decisions publicly or for outside groups to assess the consequences independently.

Displacement can damage ecosystems

Removing residents may also undermine the ecological goals of protected areas. Lokyitsang traces industrial extraction in Tibet, including deforestation and mining, to the period following the 1950 invasion. The source reports that communities have also faced mining and river dam projects. These pressures sit uneasily alongside park branding that emphasizes pristine nature.

Research increasingly recognizes that people have shaped ecosystems, including landscapes often described as wild. Indigenous stewardship has influenced environments across North America, while research on the Amazon has documented long-standing human influence on forest ecosystems. In Tibet, Dhongdue argues, nomads and other residents should be recognized as environmental actors whose accumulated knowledge matters to conservation.

A report from the Institute for Security & Development Policy presents evidence linking the removal of Tibetans from high-altitude areas to increased erosion, biodiversity loss and land degradation. These findings challenge the assumption that reducing human presence automatically improves ecological conditions. Where communities have managed land for generations, conservation plans that exclude them may lose practices and knowledge that support habitat health.

What conservation groups can say

International groups and journalists once discussed their work in China more openly, including park visits and showcase projects that provided some Tibetans with housing or lower-level park jobs. Critics say such examples can obscure larger questions about who controls land and who bears the costs. WWF China, The Nature Conservancy and Conservation International declined interview requests for the reporting behind these claims. Snow Leopard Trust, the Paulson Institute and Chinese nonprofit Shan Shui did not respond.

Gabriel Lafitte, an independent researcher focused on Tibet, argues that organizations working in China have to operate within restrictions that limit criticism. A 2016 law requires foreign nonprofit organizations operating in China to have annual plans approved by a Chinese government branch, according to the source. Lafitte says the constraints can also place staff at risk when statements provoke a response. These pressures may help explain why organizations avoid speaking publicly about displacement, though silence also leaves communities’ accounts less visible.

The practical test for China’s park system is whether it can protect wildlife while respecting the people who live within its boundaries. That means weighing conservation results alongside displacement, land degradation and the role of local stewardship. Park acreage and species protection matter, but they cannot tell the whole story. The long-term health of these ecosystems will depend in part on whether the people who know them best can help shape how they are managed.

Source: Nithin Coca · therevelator.org

From the same basket